Can't restore from backup

I am trying to move my FreePBX settings from one server to another so I can switch out a larger server for a smaller one. Before doing this, I made sure both Elastix installations were up to date and made sure all FreePBX modules were of equivalent versions, etc. Then, after moving the file over to the new box and restoring, none of the settings seem to be there. Any suggestions?

I know that backup restore is completely broken when moving between versions, but this time, versions were identical–only the hardware changed.