Unable to restore backup

I have a backup of a system I need to move to some new hardware, and I can’t get the restore to take. It goes through the motions as if it were going to work, doesn’t show any errors, but the changes are not applied to the config. Below is the result in the popup, let me know if there are any specific logs I can post:

Restoring files...
/bin/tar: ./etc/freepbx.conf: Cannot open: File exists
/bin/tar: Error exit delayed from previous errors
File restore complete!
Restoring CDR's...
Getting CDR size...
Processed 100% of CDR's!
Restoring CDR's complete
Restoring settings...
Getting Settings size...
Processed 100% of Settings's!
Restoring astDB...
Restoring Settings's complete
Running post-restore hooks, if any...
Cleaning up...
Restore complete!
Reloading...
Done!

And without restoring the freepbx.conf file (same result - no changes applied):

Intialized!!
Intializing Restore...
Running pre-restore hooks, if any...
Restoring files...
File restore complete!
Restoring CDR's...
Getting CDR size...
Processed 100% of CDR's!
Restoring CDR's complete
Restoring settings...
Getting Settings size...
Processed 100% of Settings's!
Restoring astDB...
Restoring Settings's complete
Running post-restore hooks, if any...
Cleaning up...
Restore complete!
Reloading...

No entries are logged in /var/log/httpd/error_log during the restore. Asterisk does reload when it is complete. Running watch ls -lh /etc/asterisk shows the size of the directory go from 332k to 444k during the restore, then back to 332 after the reload is complete. Any ideas?

Should add that both machines are running the latest version.

What version are they running of backup. Telling us latest means nothing. I know their was a new version released recently

Also based on your logs you are only backing up and restoring the databases. Does the database show the new data?