Hello everyone, I know the hot debate that goes on here about VLAN’s, Free PBX and QoS. I am more leaning towards, I don’t need more VLANS with my new VoIP setup but want to explain my scenario and get confirmation on my thought process with this.
We are a large K-12 environment that spans 3 large geographical areas. We have 30 sites, and staff per site ranges from about 5 - 60 per site. All staff will get a VoIP phone. We are blessed to have fibre on a government network between all of these schools that we operate our VLANS on. We have one flat named VLAN, with routing between all sites to flow traffic. On all the Edge devices, QoS is on and DSCP 46 and 26 traffic (SIP and RTP) are designated as Priority 3 and 5, accordingly, with DSCP 46 being Priority 5 Expedited Forwarding.
We Use Grandstream phones that are already set to mark RTP traffic as DSCP 46, and SIP traffic as DCSP 26, for layer 3 routing which all of our edge devices support as mentioned above. So all of our traffic in the current our current network is prioritized using DSCP, to ensure QoS. Since QoS doesn’t kick in until the shared interface for the edge devices is congested, and that interface and bandwidth is shared for all VLAN’s I don’t see the need to VLAN or QoS any more since A. another VLAN wouldn’t help, the traffic is already segmented via VLANs and Subnets, and B QoS is on…I don’t see any advantage at this point since QoS is already implemented and so are any needed VLAN’s. In my eyes, if the edge interface becomes congested for a site, a VLAN is not going to help, and QoS will prioritize the traffic, in the same way, no matter what VLAN is implemented, they are separate entities. QoS and CoS work the way they work with the DSCP protocol, and priority 1 - 7. In my eyes, my thinking is sane and clear on this. Do I seem sane, does my logic seem correct. I will also say to date our calls have been crystal clear, with this scheme. We are about to expand voip now to more sites.